NCAA DIII Baseball Program

Bethany College Baseball - WV

Bethany College baseball competes at the NCAA DIII level in Presidents Athletic Conference and is based in Bethany, WV. Campus enrollment is about 614 students. The published acceptance rate is 59%. Recent baseball results include 2026: 26-17. Listed coaches include Michael Finlan, Peter Toula, Tyler Shaneyfelt, Logan Bennett, and Riley Brendel.

Open School Page Team Site Recruit Questionnaire School Site Browse all programs

Program Snapshot

  • Location: Bethany, WV
  • Division: NCAA DIII
  • Conference: Presidents Athletic Conference
  • School type: Private nonprofit
  • Campus setting: Rural: Fringe (rural territory up to 5 miles from an urbanized area or up to 2.5 miles from an urban cluster)
  • Enrollment: 614 students
  • Enrollment by sex: 59% men / 41% women
  • Acceptance rate: 59%
  • Source: U.S. Dept. of Education
  • Average annual cost: $18,605
  • In-state tuition: $36,765
  • Out-of-state tuition: $36,765

Coaching Staff

  • Michael Finlan, Head Coach
  • Peter Toula, Assistant Coach
  • Tyler Shaneyfelt, Graduate Assistant
  • Logan Bennett, Assistant Coach
  • Riley Brendel, Assistant Coach

Recent Baseball Results

  • 2026: 26-17
  • 2025: 26-17-1
  • 2024: 10-28
  • 2023: 18-22
  • 2022: 16-23

Members-only details for Bethany College

Members see direct contact details for the coaching staff: 4 email addresses, 1 phone number, and 3 X accounts.

The 2025-26 roster breakdown is available to members, including class makeup, position depth by class, expected openings after this season, handedness, average height and weight by position, and where players come from.

Become a Member $14.99/mo or $149/yr · cancel anytime

Conference: Presidents Athletic Conference

Other schools in the PAC

Similar schools