Mike Williams is the recruiting coordinator and pitching coach at the University of St. Thomas, an NCAA Division III program in Houston. On Episode 122 of the Baseball Forward Podcast he told Ross Hawley where Division III fits today and why his staff recruits with innings instead of a logo. This guide answers the questions parents bring to us most often, using his points.
Watch the full conversation on YouTube
Where does Division III fit in today's recruiting picture?
Williams says the transfer portal is pushing players down a level. That has changed where a high school player can find a chance to develop, and it is part of why a Division III program with innings to give matters.
He also offers a reality check. By his count, only about 3% of players go on to play college baseball, yet many families assume years of lessons and top select teams add up to a Division I spot. He invites parents to watch a Division III game in person. The gap he sees is mostly depth. UST scrimmages a Division I opponent in the fall and one in the spring, along with Division II St. Edward's in the spring, and his team usually holds its own early before a bigger staff's depth takes over.
For more on how the portal and travel ball shape the calendar, read exposure, timing, travel ball, and the transfer portal.
Is it smarter to play right away than to join a bigger program?
Williams frames it as a choice between two freshman years. At a bigger school, the kind of player he recruits might throw 10 innings or get 20 at-bats. At UST, Williams talks about 75 innings or 200 at-bats in that first season.
For the 2027 class, the opening is specific. UST is graduating three conference starters and its Tuesday starter, with bullpen roles on top of that, and he points to 175 innings. His message to those pitchers: the jobs are there, so come in and earn them. A famous program can be a great experience, he says, but the real question is whether a player wants to play or to sit.
"D3 might be your first step and then if you do well there, then you'll get that opportunity to go to the D1 level after that, but you've got to get on the field."
If your family is still sorting out which level fits, our guide to communication and choosing a level is a good next read.
What should we check on a roster before saying yes?
Look at who a program already signed at your son's position. Williams uses catchers as his example. If a school just added five catchers, a sixth is unlikely to play soon, while another program with none committed in that class may offer a spot right away. A player who produces early can show it, look at the portal later if he chooses, and still reach his goal a couple of years down the road.
Our Game Plan tool can help you keep that position-by-position list organized.
Will a freshman get a fair shot at UST?
Williams says yes, and he says it to recruits up front. Players hear that holding on to their spot is their job, and that recruiting is the staff's job. Every pitcher throws in the fall, position players get the same number of at-bats, and freshmen know they can win a job right away. The seniors know it too.
That competition has not driven players out. Williams puts the program's retention rate at 95% and credits head coach Torry Peterson for the culture. He describes a staff of three player-type coaches who put an arm around a player after a mistake and work through the fix, and he believes player-led teams win championships.
"We don't hunt the portal, we develop."
What does the University of St. Thomas look for in a recruit?
On the mound:
- Pitchers who are not afraid to work inside and who challenge hitters with the fastball in fastball counts
- Power sinkers and good two-seamers
- A willingness to own the inner half. Williams says UST had the conference's top pitching staff last year because it pitched inside.
In the field and at the plate:
- Backspin line drives into the gap
- Hard running out of the box
- A dirty uniform at the end of the game from sliding or diving
- The first player out of the dugout, and a player who talks and communicates
Williams also tells recruits he does not care which select team or high school they come from. If a pitcher can get outs, he can have success.
How should a player reach out to the UST staff?
Start on X. Williams checks his direct messages as often as his email, and at camps and events he asks recruits to tag the staff in their videos. The coaches cannot be at every event, so a short clip, about two minutes, is often what starts things. If the staff sees something it likes, the next step is arranging to watch the player in person, and then a visit.
Be honest about fit before you send it. As Ross put it on the episode, the player has to be able to play. Send video that shows it. Coach Williams is @Williams_Mike44, and the program is @USTCeltsBSB.
Keep researching
- See the University of St. Thomas program page for location, cost, and roster details.
- Compare other Division III programs in the school directory.
- Create a DIY Account for direct coach contact information, program insights, and a spot in the Prospect List shared with college programs. Want Ross to introduce you to schools? See guided plans.